sticky innovation & biodesign challenge

  • home
    • sticky innovation FAQ
    • instructors
  • Biodesign Challenge
    • BDC 2019
    • BDC 2020
  • SI Fall 2021
  • SI Fall 2019
    • content
    • projects
    • student reflections
  • SI Fall 2018
    • Student Reflections
    • Ideal Bee
    • Drawing as Research
    • Field Experiences
    • Are.na Research Channel
  • SI Fall 2016
    • content >
      • syllabus and calendar
      • aesthetics assignment
      • watch
      • read
      • make
      • reflections 2016
    • class activities >
      • site visit
      • ideal bee
      • sleepy bee
      • blog
    • digital portfolios
  • home
    • sticky innovation FAQ
    • instructors
  • Biodesign Challenge
    • BDC 2019
    • BDC 2020
  • SI Fall 2021
  • SI Fall 2019
    • content
    • projects
    • student reflections
  • SI Fall 2018
    • Student Reflections
    • Ideal Bee
    • Drawing as Research
    • Field Experiences
    • Are.na Research Channel
  • SI Fall 2016
    • content >
      • syllabus and calendar
      • aesthetics assignment
      • watch
      • read
      • make
      • reflections 2016
    • class activities >
      • site visit
      • ideal bee
      • sleepy bee
      • blog
    • digital portfolios

follow the buzz
 individual research topics 

Adjuvants: The Silent Bee Killer

9/29/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Written by: Karissa Schroeter

An adjuvant is defined as a pharmacological agent that modifies the effect of other agents. Adjuvants are currently used in both the medical and agricultural fields (which are from a production/business standpoint closely intertwined). In agriculture, it is used to enhance a pesticide/ funcide/ insecticde / herbicide/ agricultural spray's effectiveness. Adjuvants can either be "in can", which means they are added into the pesticide before it is sold to the public or "tank mix", which means farmers purchase and add it to pesticides on their own.

Examples of adjuvants include:
  • Surfactants
  • Emulsifiers
  • Oils
  • Salts

​




​

After having worked closely with BASF's agricultural business as an engineering co-op at the Cincinnati site having been lucky enough to be a part of organizing the ISAA, International Symposium for Agricultural Adjuvants, held on June 13-17th, 2016 in Monterrey, CA, something hit me. Adjuvants are essentially unregulated in the United States (and very lightly regulated everywhere else). WA & CA require preregistration of adjuvants before they are sold and the effectiveness of adjuvants is measured by ASTM Int & CPDA but that is it. Why are pesticides heavily regulated but adjuvants are not at all?

Tank mix adjuvants can literally transform a mild, approved pesticide into a "super pesticide" and they are virtually unregulated and are not tested for their toxicity to the environment (let alone humans!). Farmers no longer simply use one pesticide or insecticide as they did in the past. Today, farmers use a complex chemical mix of products including adjuvants. 

A big study in 2012 came out that proved that organosilicone surfactants caused learning impairment in honeybees. When colony collapse disorder struck millions of bees in CA, research was done to figure out what happened to cause the mass deaths. It was discovered that an  organosilicone surfactant (untested) was used on almond trees in CA along with a BASF fungicide (tested and confirmed non-toxic alone) and a Chemtura insecticide (tested and confirmed non-toxic alone). Scientists concluded that that specific mix of adjuvants, pesticides, and fungicides is what had poisoned, disoriented, and then killed the bees. The mixture proved to be an endocrine disruptor in bees. 

Picture
Picture

​If both companies and farmers know that adjuvants are an integral part of the collective process, why are agricultural products tested individually? And why ignore adjuvant products when making regulations and requirements?

Money. The current lack of regulations and requirements for adjuvant products makes life a whole  lot easier for both the companies that produce adjuvants and the farmers that purchase them. There is a conflict of interest with adjuvants and the Principle Agent and Moral Hazard Problems comes into play. 

Currently, the push in adjuvant technology is entirely performance driven. There is no push for regulations or concern for the health of bees. If all agents involved with adjuvants continue to pursue their self interest without regards for the greater good, then the bees will continue to be harmed by these adjuvants and the wicked problem will continue to escalate. What is needed now is education of the public and the creation/enforcement of regulations for adjuvants.

Sources:
http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0040848
http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/PressReleases/adjuvant.asp
http://psep.cce.cornell.edu/facts-slides-self/facts/gen-peapp-adjuvants.aspx​
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_spray_adjuvant​
1 Comment

Health and Honey | Isaiah Postenrieder

9/28/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
​Conduct a Google search for the health benefits of honey and a sprawling list of organic food and health and fitness websites will appear. Hundreds of websites will claim seemingly minor or more radical benefits of honey. Conduct a similar search for royal jelly and the claims will become more outlandish. Several sources claim that honey and royal jelly will cure menopause and male infertility. Are these health benefits replicable and observable or anecdotal? Let’s examine three more often claimed benefits of honey: weight loss, improved athletic performance, and improved memory.
 
First, in general, the National Honey Board states, “a tablespoon of raw honey contains 64 calories, is fat-free, cholesterol-free, and sodium-free,” and royal jelly contains “vitamin B5 and other B vitamins, biotin, inositol, folate, nucleic acids, gamma globulin and 17 different amino acids, including the eight essential amino acids that the human body cannot produce.” Honey contains nutrients such as protein, water, fiber, sugars and various vitamins and minerals. Fiber and other nutrients are essential to dissolve fats and cholesterol. While claiming honey contributes to weight loss may be an exaggeration, it is certainly a better sweet alternative than sugar or artificial sweeteners. Honey has also been shown to lower weight gain, adiposity, and triglycerides than sucrose in rats.
 
Next, honey has been shown to boost athletic performance. Richard Kreider of the University of Memphis Exercise and Sport Nutrition Laboratory stated, "Most of the studies to date have shown supplementation with glucose to provide the extra staying power. We were pleased to find that honey, a 'cocktail' of various natural sugars, performed just as well." Honey, being a natural source of carbohydrates, is a great boost for exercise.
 
Lastly, a study has claimed that women experienced a boost in memory after eating twenty grams of honey a day. However, some have criticized the study for the lack of a blind procedure. Stanford researcher Dr. Victor Henderson stated that perceived memory problems are often not real when examined objectively. If there is real concern, memory issues are most likely related to depression, sleep problems, or medication. Also, some voiced concerns over the amount of honey the participants were required to eat.
 
Clearly, raw honey does have nutritional and health benefits. While it may not be a cure-all for all ailments, it can greatly help weight loss and athletic performance. Currently, one is not able to conclude that honey can cure memory loss or other more serious conditions.

Sources:

www.academia.edu/3228620/Improvement_in_immediate_memory_after_16_weeks_of_tualang_honey_Agro_Mas_supplement_in_healthy_postmenopausal_women
www.honey.com/honey-at-home/honeys-natural-benefits/natures-energy-food
www.medicaldaily.com/liquid-gold-7-health-benefits-honey-could-heal-your-whole-body-325932
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21310307
www.reuters.com/article/us-honey-memory-idUSTRE79D5LH20111014
www.scientificamerican.com/article/honey-heightens-athletic/

Image:
http://www.healthandbeauty23.com/health-benefits-of-honey/

0 Comments

The Time Value of Honey

9/22/2016

1 Comment

 
According to the Honey Association, it's hard to tell how long honey has been collected by humans since the earliest records are from the beginnings of recorded history. Early cave paintings show ancient humans gathering honey.
Picture
Over the years honey has been used for a variety of things in a variety of cultures. In ancient cultures, honey and bees was used as a symbol of royalty. Bees were the symbol of popes, Greek and Egyptian gods, and stamped on currency.  Napoleon used bees on his flag carried into battle.

Picture
Honey was also used a sweetener since ancient times. This use as a sweetener continued through Egypt and Greece cultures, and was continued to be used commonly in European cultures up until the Renaissance. During the Renaissance, sugar imported from other countries started to widely replace honey as a sweetener.

A final use of honey throughout history is for medicinal purposes. Below is a short video describing honey and beeswax as a medicine in Egypt.

Sources
http://www.honeyassociation.com/index.asp?pid=9
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/47/Cueva_arana.jpg
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/158/438066808_92609772e8_b.jpg
http://www.infoelba.com/discovering-elba/curious-facts/the-flag-of-the-island-of-elba/

1 Comment

Buckfast Bee | Jessica Francis

9/20/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Brother Adam, a monk at Buckfast Abbey, began beekeeping for the abbey when he was twelve when he was apprenticed under Brother Columband. In 1915, when Brother Adam was 16 they lost the majority of their beehives to a plague of acarine disease named after the parasitic tracheal mite which caused the wipeout of so many hives. The sixteen hives that lived were all either pure Italian or of Italian descent. The hives also did not show any trace of the disease that killed so many others. This observation inspired Brother Adam, who began to selectively breed his queens. The government asked the abbey to increase the number of hives they had in order to help replenish the bees that died to the plague throughout the country.

Brother Adam took to studying the traits of pure strains of bees from foreign countries and importing them to an isolated valley where he could breed his bees in peace. It seems to have taken him about ten years per strain to achieve a stable cross of desired genes. The end result became the Buckfast bee which is a famous be around the world.

Brother Adam’s success is one of the first and biggest modern selective bee breeding program. He used bee breeding stations to let select the queens and later be able to select the drones. He bred his bees and then left them for a time to allow them to be naturally selected for. He only used queens that came from successful hives in his breeding program. And as I mentioned it took ten years to get a trait to stick. He was patient with his bees and gave them time. Brother Adam knew how to learn from the bees and find the best balance that works for both bees and humans.
​
The problem we face today is much more widespread than Brother Adam’s plague. I was unable to find specific information on whether colony collapse affects Buckfast bees. Regardless, I would like to suggest that a gentler, more patient approach to selectively breeding bees than artificial insemination may be more effective in the long run. 
Picture
Sources

http://www.pedigreeapis.org/elver/ori/origin-en.html
http://www.buckfast.org.uk/bee-keeping_150.html
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2015/05/building-bees/mann-text
https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1259:_Bee_Orchid
​
1 Comment

Bee Venom: Harmful or Healthy? | Othman Adil

9/8/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture

Most of us have the natural instinct of waving frantically at the air, twisting around and sprinting in the opposite direction when we see the black and yellow winged creatures we know as bees. This is mainly due to the fear of being stung by the bee; we remember being innocent children playing at the park until our skin is pierced by the sharp stinger of a bee, leading to yelling and crying and our skin becoming a site of redness, itching and pain. Bee venom, however, may serve a hidden purpose aside from inciting panic in everyone not working as a beekeeper. 

For more than 5,000 years, ancient civilizations have used bee venom as a therapeutic measure to fight against disease and injury. As time progressed, the world has grown and moved onto developing antibiotics and other precise drugs to fight diseases such as tuberculosis, pneumonia, and polio. Bee venom therapy has not been completely lost though; scientists have found a unique group of 13 bacteria that live in honeybee's stomachs which have had strong counteracting abilities toward powerful infectious bacteria including MRSA, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and VRE. These findings present a promising future for treatment of many diseases especially due to the antibiotic-resistant bacteria epidemic, however more tests are needed to further determine the clinical potential of honeybee belly bacteria.

In addition to fighting bacterial causes of disease, bee venom has also been used in many countries as a way of counteracting the debilitating symptoms of Multiple Sclerosis and Rheumatoid Arthritis. Although many patients provide anecdotal evidence of their symptoms being ameliorated after trying bee venom as a treatment. However, larger and more precise studies are required to determine the efficacy of these treatments.

So how can honeybee venom help those of us without these diseases? Gwyneth Paltrow, a notable Hollywood actress, has admitted to using bee venom therapy as a source of skin therapy, making her look 23 instead of 43.  In the video below, Allure insider Shannon Ray tests this method herself by getting a bee venom facial! 

​
Sources

Olofsson, T. C., Butler, È., Markowicz, P., Lindholm, C., Larsson, L. and Vásquez, A. (2014), Lactic acid bacterial symbionts in honeybees – an unknown key to honey's antimicrobial and therapeutic activities. Int Wound J. doi:10.1111/iwj.12345

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/gwyneth-paltrow-apitherapy-bee-stings_us_5702b0dde4b083f5c6084d59

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16541972

​
0 Comments

The Queen Bee 

9/6/2016

1 Comment

 

Written By Celeste Bauer

Picture

You’ve all heard the expression “the queen bee” referring to someone who is in charge with implicit qualities of strength. But what makes a queen bee a queen? How are we changing the process? And is it for better or worse?
 
Naturally when bees are born they feed on royal jelly for the first three days and then they feed on beebread, but queen bees receive royal jelly for their entire larva state. Once a queen bee is born she goes around and stings the rest of the queen larva so she is the only queen bee. When queens are reared in a lab they are grafted, that is, the larva of a worker cell in a breeder’s beehive is transferred to an artificial queen cell. One research paper compared the resulting queen bee’s hives absconding tendency (colony collapse syndrome), brood area, honey harvest, mite infestation, and swarming tendency to that of naturally reared queen bees. This study showed that the grafted queens, on average, resulted with larger brood area and honey harvest and with a smaller swarming tendency (which can be considered both a good thing and bad thing), absconding tendency, and mite infestation. (Note: the queen bees in this study were inseminated by a contained and manipulated swarm.)
 
The second critical part of a queen bee’s life cycle is their insemination. Naturally queen bees have a swarm after birth where hundreds of drones (male bees) inseminate her. In labs, queen bees are artificially inseminated with one type of sperm. The natural process results in a higher genetic diversity which, based on theories like Darwinism, natural selection, and the theory of evolution, results in the stronger genetic bees becoming more predominate. This is why some scientists think this could help solve the bee mite problem that is arising and contributing to the bee population decline. Similarly, in nature, only the toughest queens survive to take over the colony. All of this helps to produce bees that are stronger and less likely to die from disease.  In addition, when bees swarm, all of the drones that mate with the queen die. This helps alleviate the burden of the drones on the hive because they serve very little purpose other then that.
 
This directly pertains to the ‘wicked’ bee problem we have been discussing in class. Stronger bees mean stronger hives that are able to withstand disease and, ultimately, not only survive through the years but also thrive. If we manifest a way to breed stronger queen bees that yield a stronger hive, the outcome could contribute to helping solve the decline in bees that we are seeing globally.

 
Sources:
http://www.entomoljournal.com/vol3Issue2/pdf/3-2-11.1.pdf
http://www.waldeneffect.org/blog/Natural_vs._artificial_bee_reproduction/

http://www.news.cornell.edu/stories/2011/12/decision-making-bee-swarms-mimics-brains

1 Comment

Stagnant Evolution

9/6/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Bees and humans have co-existed for thousands of years, and as humanity has advanced they have attempted to improve their end of the bargain through many practices to increase hive productivity as well as increasing the number of hives available.

A widely used tactic to increase hive number is the process of artificial insemination. This almost universal tactic allows queen breeders to turn out many hives in a short amount of time with relatively high success. An uptick in the demand for bees in many places (California being a leading buyer of these mass produced hives) has turned what was once a small and local practice of raising bees into a commercial powerhouse with implications far outreaching the profit.

The process of breeding queens is a complex one requiring skill and mainly trial and error. The process was described in great detail in "Breeding improved Honey Bees..." by William C. Roberts and Otto Mackensen. This garish looking process requires the inseminator to literally squash a male bee to extract the sperm which is then forcefully inserted into the queen. The queen is then left to lay her eggs in the hive undisturbed until the next mating season where the inseminator must go through the same process in order to keep the stocks pure. Other methods of inbreeding are non-viable and cause the hive to turn on itself, so this method is the only option for beekeepers using inbred bees. Even though this method is viable, it is necessary to go through multiple rounds of bees and use "tester" lines in order to ensure the manifestation of desired traits in the bees. This process leaves multiple rounds of bees necessary in order to create one desired type. There are obviously observable benefits to this practice; one example being that, more often than not, gentleness is increased in bees that have been inbred. There are also many potential downsides to this worldwide process. With inbreeding, all traits are fixed. This means that both the good, and more notably the bad, are in the bloodline to stay with each new generation unless differing genetic material is introduced. Thus, damaging traits continue to be passed down as the evolution of bee-kind grinds down to a previously unobserved halt. This lack of change in the genetic structure of bees has led to an explosion in problems facing the bees -- most notably, the Varroa Destructor mite. Without variation in brood, these problems will continue and worsen as the bee's natural enemies continue to adapt uninterrupted by humanity.
Picture
Picture
In a study conducted by John R. Harbo and Tibor I. Szabo, naturally mated queens' lifespan and the efficiency of their hives was compared to that of a queen who had been artificially inseminated in a lab. At all locations the study observed, "the colonies with [naturally mated] queens had 21-73% more capped brood in may... than did colonies with [artificially inseminated] queens". Brood is the hive's young, and as demonstrated by this study, the influence of humans in the brood production process leads to far fewer viable bees. The study also observed a marked increase in honey production from the naturally mated queens over the artificially inseminated variety. With more honey comes a healthier and better-fed hive with increased surplus to spare for the happy, human consumer. The increase in honey also illustrates an increase in pollination which is important for crop production and the continuation of certain species of plant that require pollination to reproduce.

What must be garnered from this compilation of observation is the disastrous effect of playing God. The more we meddle, the more "Wicked Problems" we create which compound and intertwine. Scaling back operations is the only way to allow nature to heal, and the problems we have caused to rectify themselves.

Adam Pozdro

First Year Industrial Design Student
​Hobbyest Beekeeper

Sources

Print Sources:
  1. Harbo, John R., and Tibor I. Szabo. "A Comparison of Instrumentally Inseminated and Naturally Mated Queens." Journal of Apicultural Research 23.1 (1983): 31-36. A Comparison of Instrumentally Inseminated and Naturally Mated Queens: : Vol 23, No 1. 24 Mar. 2015. Web. 06 Sept. 2016.
  2. ​Roberts, William C., and Otto Mackensen. "Breeding Improved Honey Bees, Part 4: Inbred and Hybrid Bees." American Bee Journal 91 (1951): 418-21. Beesource Beekeeping. Web. 04 Sept. 2016
Image Sources:
  1. ​N.d. Birds & Bees Honey. Web. 7 Sept. 2016.
  2. Instrumental Insemination of Honeybees - Extracting Semen. YouTube. N.p., 27 June 2012. Web. 7 Sept. 2016.
    • Video
  3. BiteSizeVegan. "Is Honey Vegan? Healthy? Humane?" YouTube. YouTube, 14 May 2014. Web. 07 Sept. 2016.
    1. Video
      ​
1 Comment

(Sample Blog Post) TITLE: Landmark Sculpture Park Showcases Art about Bees by Nandita Baxi Sheth (your name)

8/18/2016

1 Comment

 
 (TEXT-approximately 150 words or more  explaining what the research is about and how it connects to our readings and in class discussions)
Artists Meg Webster and Jessica Segall have created site specific sculptural work connecting to the theme of bees and pollination in the LANDMARK installation in Socrates Sculpture Park in Long Island City, Queens, New York. ...........more words.....here...........

The Presentation of your Post should take 3-5 minutes.
Picture
 (CITATION)
Sources and Photo Credits
http://hyperallergic.com/306308/a-mini-ecosystem-creates-a-buzz-at-socrates-sculpture-park/
​http://socratessculpturepark.org/exhibition/landmark/
Please check weblinks to make sure they are "hot"
Grading Rubric
Title, Name, Text, Image/s, Citation (2pts)
Relevance: Content Connection to Class and Readings (2pts)
Presentation (1pt)

1 Comment
Forward>>

    ened | arte 3040

    class blog

    Archives

    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

#stickyinnovation #ucbdc           Copyright © 2021